cymbalta inot for children under 18. people taking maois, linezolid or thioridazine or with uncontrolled glaucoma should not take cymbalta. taking it with nsaid pain relievers, aspirin, or blood thinners may increase bleeding risk. severe liver problems, some fatal, were reported. signs include abdominal pain and yellowing skin or eyes. tell your doctor about all your medicines, including those for migraine and while on cymbalta, call right away if you have high fever, confusion and stiff muscles or serious allergic skin reactions like blisters, peeling rash, hives, or mouth sores to address possible life-threatening conditions. talk about your alcohol use, lir disease and before you reduce or stop cymbalta. dizziness or fainting may occur upon standing. take the next step. talk to your doctor. cymbalta can help. ...but he'd wait for her forever, for any reason, and would always be there with the biggest welcome home. for a love this strong, dawn only feeds him iams. compared to other leading brands,

it has 50% more animal protein. ...to help keep rocky's body as strong as a love that never fades... if he ever lets her leave again. iams. keep love strong. >> judge jeanine: they are regular people. any work hard. they save for their dream vacation. but what do you do when the dream turns into a nightmare? when you are held captive on a

virtual cruise from hell? hello and welcome to "justice." i'm judge jeanine pirro. it is sunday morning, day three of a four day cruise. fire erupts and all of the power goes out and for the next five days 4200 people on carnival's cruiseship triumph are adrift on a ship without power. that means no hot water. no electricity. no running toilets. and no real food. so much for the unlimited buffet. so it left me looking for answers. what is the history of this ship? did it have any previous problems? alas, just a few weeks earlier the same ship had an engine room problem that caused its cruises to be canceled. and lest i forget, this is a carnival cruiseline.

engine fires not really uncommon. last year the casa' alegra a fire in the engine room causes it to go adrift. the spendor, 2010, fire in the engine room, adrift. the ecstasy. the star princess. the royal princess. each with their own problems. get my drift? >> there was no water -- >> why there was no emergency plan in place? passengers report total chaos walking on urine soaked feces encrusted floors eating ketchup and onion sandwiches. and i brought some here for you. ketchup and onions. so i say why wasn't food air dropped for these people. we do it for foreign countries all the time. >> people started hoarding food into their bags and back packs and were running away with food and then there was food

shortages and they kept stopping serving food so you would go up and there would about he no food and you would be waiting in line for hours on end. >> judge jeanine: why did it take so long to get a generator. another cruiseship dropped off hamburgers and chicken from which it is reported many became sick and over which fights erupted over why there was no provision for wheel chair bound passengers? since the elevator didn't work they were held captive on the floor they were on. >> we are focused on our guests and getting them on their jurisdictionry home. >> judge jeanine: really? when the power went out if you were so focused on getting your guests home. the ship was 150-miles from mexico. 500 miles from alabama. the math is simple. since the cruise is over the next day go to mexico. get them home. but the decision was made to go

to alabama. could it be because it was cheaper to go to the states? then you only have to bus people home and they had about 100 buses versus paying for airfare from mexico? plus why put more miles on the ship. >> it could have been a serious catastrophe really. so they are just very lucky that we didn't end up burning in the ship because no alarms went off. they told us to go back to bed while the fire was burning. >> but isn't it interesting that the last night, the passengers received for their last supper steak and lobster. for their closeup, carnival cruise lines doesn't allow the old ketchup and onion sandwich. the deck is pristine. no longer smelling of feces and

urine. urinein strong enough to burn your eyes and the feces crusting on your toes. then they had the music play on. what is the recourse? the ticket language limits the ability to recover and even sue. maritime law bars passengers from recovering damages from emotional stress. unless you have been physically injured i no damages. i think congress needs to get involved because the rights are cruiseship passengers are almost nonexistent at a time when the business is literally exploding. what is that you say? this will be investigated. yes. but by whom? oh, yeah, the bahamaian government. isn't that where an attempt was made to blackmail john travolta right after his own son died.

i have always believed the punishment should fit the crime. here is my sentence. all execs of carnival including the ceo will be sentenced as follows. their jail cell a porta potty and a smelly one at that. conditions of their incarceration that they walk in feces encrusted and urine soaked rugs, have no shower and no water and eat the old bread onions and ketchup sandwich and they are fined $10,000 times 4,200 people. and by the way that includes the crew members who literally prevented an all out mutiny. with me is matt who with his wife was a passenger on the carnival triumph. he plans to sue carnival in a class action. he joins us from oklahoma city and also with us michael

winkleman, matt's attorney. you were a marine. how bad was it? >> conditions were pretty bad. everything you said so far is very accurate. the beginning when the fire broke out at 5:30 in the morning everybody scrambled to the muster stations and really didn't know what was going on. >> judge jeanine: did they tell you that there was a fire? >> not initially. but you could smell the smoke bellowing through the hallways. >> judge jeanine: do you think the ship was prepared for even the possibility of this happening? >> that is really why i came on it because i don't think that they were well prepared. their history shows that they are blatantly negligent to implement contingency plans to ensure passenger safety. >> judge jeanine: and so what happened to those individuals

who were in wheel chairs, the elderly, i understand that a woman cracked her head an elderly senior citizen, that a girl, someone broke her ankle and her foot was hanging from her leg. i mean did you see all this, matt? >> i did. i saw the -- i felt bad for the young children, the babies who were on a limited is you ply of diapers. they were rationing out the diapers that were onboard. the elderly were pretty much stuck where they were at with no way of getting anywhere and people would just bring them food. >> judge jeanine: yeah. michael, i'm going go to you. you represent matt. what is the basis of his claim and can you really expect to recover given the fact that there is limited liability pursuant to the ticket?

>> sure. first, good evening, your honor. nice to see you. thanks for having me back and matt and all of the 3,000 passengers absolutely have a right to file a claim. it is eception isly a combination of negligence infliction of emotional disclaim and intentional infliction of emotional distress claim. >> you need to show physical injury, don't you? for all of the people who suffered the stress of backing through the feces infested carpets and fighting over food and the mess that is emotional trauma. is that recoverable? >> it absolutely is, judge. you are talking about the zone of danger test and in some jurisdictions it does require a physical manifestation and from what i heard and seen the evidence will openly show from the facts that all of these people have a right to recover under the law for negligence infliction of emotional duress and intentional infliction of emotional distress. >> judge jeanine: why would you

say intentional? >> i do. i think you were hitting the hail on the head. it was about putting profits over people's safety. when they were 150 miles from mexico they intentionally decided to go 500 miles away back to the united states for money. instead of getting the people off the ship they he intentionally decided to drag them across the gulf of mexico for five grueling awful days and subjected them to the awful deplorable conditions. >> judge jeanine: add to the fact that for five extra days people weren't able to plan for baby sit isers, pet sitters, you get your check stolen in the mail. >> they couldn't work. they are losing wages. you got it, judge. >> judge jeanine: $500 doesn't cover any of that. >> none of it. i called it laughable and i think that is a valid statement and i know matt feels the same way about it. really almost insulting. why does carnival get to pick a number out of thin air as to what they think is fair for this. a jury should ultimately decide

how much is a fair and just compensation for exactly what was done to people like matt. >> judge jeanine: i agree. thanks for being with us this evening. >> thanks, judge. >> thank you. >> judge jeanine: and later, they are each accused of killing loved ones. jodi and oscar pistorius up next, if you have a cruise planned, how do you know if your ship is safe? ♪ come sail away, come sail away, come and sail away with me ♪ [ roasting firewood ]

♪ many hot dogs are within you. try pepto-bismol to-go, it's the power of pepto, but it fits in your pocket. now tell the world daniel... of pepto-bismol to-go.

♪ rock the boat, don't rock the boat, baby, don't tip the boat over ♪ >> judge jeanine: the investigation underway into the fire that crippled the triumph and led to the cruise from hell. should this disaster have been

avoided? joining me is former ntsb former board member dr. vernon gross. thanks for being with us this evening. >> you're welcome, your honor. >> judge jeanine: the reports are there were problems with the ship just weeks before it left on this cruise. what can you tell us about this? >> well, we know good and well, there is no mystery here at all. you recited a bit already of what i would call indictment of what they have done. the one fact that we need to know here that there is no regulation for cruiseships. they are not regulated like airlines are or railroads. or other modes of transportation. because of that, you know, there is no way to govern what they are doing. there is no way to have leverage on them if they do fail like they have done now. >> judge jeanine: let me ask you this. when you say not like the airlines. why is the cruiseship industry so different? it is a carrier of many guests who pay to get on them.

incorporated some of them in miami. why is there so much or a total lack of almost regulation of these cruiseships? >> well, i think they have gotten away so far from having regulation but there is a variety, a spectrum of cruiseship companies and i hope that the whole cruiseship industry is not judged by this one incident that just happened. this is like the wal-mart of cruiseships as i understand it. it is -- they have lower rates and so on and so they get away with a lot more than the more sophisticated ones would. here is the crest in my mind, why did this fail, this engine fail in the first place because they had one fail before, two years ago off mexico, carnival lost one as well. >> the splendor. this is not unusual. they go adrift all the time. is there any deterrent to or any punishment to these people

being derelict in making sure that these ships are are ready to go out of port again? >> this is a bahamian registration and they will conduct the investigation. the nt is sb and the coast guard will be parties to that. but they will not probably have the leverage that you would have if it was done by the ntsb. >> judge jeanine: doctor, with all due respect you were a member of the national transportation safety board. they have no jurisdiction here other than to recommend changes. nobody is going to punish carnival for this and deal unless they get a class action going here. with the trauma and stress of not having food, fighting in lines to get food. it is like a third world country. >> it really was. i'm hopeful that maybe the publicity that this created might cause them just from conscience sake to do some things they should be doing. for example, why did that engine catch fire? we need to know that. but if it caught fire, why in the world does all of the power

on the ship focused in that one engine? they should have an auxilliary power unit for scam. >> and the generator comes in the day before they go into alabama. if we air drop food for foreign countries all the time and you have people without medication because they are on the boat five days longer than they should have been, what is the problem with at least trying to get the staples that people need? >> well, if you you stop to think about this, who paid even for the towing of this ship back to mobile? >> judge jeanine: the coast guard. we did. >> yes, the taxpayers paid for that towing so they got that free. >> judge jeanine: they he ought to be forced to reimburse for that and 500 buck bucks is hog. it is not enough money. thanks for being with us this evening. >> you're welcome. >> judge jeanine: coming up, she has been on the stand for weeks in her own murder trial.

the jury got to hear her having phone sex with the very man that she killed. that tape, after the break. and vote in our instapoll, is $500 enough for the cruiseship passengers. if not, what should be? tweet me at judge jeanine or post on facebook. we will read your answers. a lot of them anyway, later in the show. hi. hi. i'm here to pick up some cacti. it should be under stephens. the verizon share everything plan for small business. get a shareable pool of data... got enough joshua trees? ... on up to 25 devices. so you can spend less time... yea, the golden barrels... managing wireless costs and technology and more time driving your business potential. looks like we're going to need to order more agaves... ah! oh! ow! ... and more bandages. that's powerful. sharble data plus unlimited talk and text. now save $50 on a droid razr maxx hd by motorola. (grayou've come to the righting to buyplace...ubaru, ...especially if you're a dog.

can you smell that leather? of course you can. your nose is amazing. you guys keep in touch. i'll get you a great deal on any trade-in, no questions asked. i have no questions! and just look at that cargo space! what? once you sit in a subaru, you'll stay. i wish my patients could see what i see. ♪ that over time, having high cholesterol and any of these risk factors can put them at increased risk for plaque buildup inheir arteries. so it's even more important to lower their cholesterol, and that's why, when diet and exercise alonaren't enough, i prescribe crestor. in a clinical trial versus lipitor, crestor got more high-risk patients' bad cholesterol to a goal of under 100. [ female announcer ] crestor is not right for everyone. like people with liver disease or women who are nursing, pregnant or may become pregnant.

tell your doctor about other medicines yore taking. ll your doctoright away if you have muscle pain or weakness, feel unusually tired, have loss of appetite, upper belly pain, dark urine or yellowing of skin or eyes. these could be signs of rare but serious side effects. ♪ is your cholesterol at goal? talk to youdoctor about crestor. [ femalannouncer ] if you can't afford your medication, astrazeneca may be able to help.

i never in my life. >> yes, you have is. when i have -- >> no. >> puffy eyes and i have off all my makeup. >> you don't look bad then either. you just look miserable but you look hot, so. >> that is funny that you say that.

thank you. >> s true. think about this. there has been many times where you have been like miserable and i have like raped you. >> this week the defense in the jodi murder case played an hour long recording of her having phone sex with the man she admits killing. their goal? to prove to the jury that travis alexander was controlling and abusive and therefore jodi killed him in self-defense. i'm joined by two people looking for two very different outcomes. travetravis alexander's friendd jodi arias' friend who joins me on the phone. travis, you knew jodi and you were a friend of travis. what did you think of her? >> well, we never really liked jodi. we were nice to her because it is just the right -- >> judge jeanine: why didn't you like her? >> jodi just had a suspicious

vibe about her from day one. today looking back it is easy to describe it as no soul but there was something she didn't click with any of our groups. we never knew much about her and she didn't open up and talk much about her background and travis normally dated girls that were easy to communicate with and talked with and got along with the rest of us very easily. >> judge jeanine: looking back on it now, do you think that he had feelings for her or was this just a sexual relationship? >> well, i know that travis con fided in some of his close friends that they had had some let's call it morality challenges and that he was working through those and trying to get through those but get slipping up and going back to her. quite honestly. >> judge jeanine: let me see if i underand it this. he had a morality challenge? what does that mean? >> what that means is according

to the beliefs of our church there is some morality rules and some guidelines that we believe are inappropriate if you are not married and he had been messing up and violating those rules. >> judge jeanine: does that mean he shouldn't have had intercourse with her? >> that's correct. >> judge jeanine: so he shouldn't have premarital relations. >> correct. >> judge jeanine: that tape recording, it was his voice, something about raping jodi. does that surprise you to hear that in your friend's voice? >> you know, it doesn't surprise me from the standpoint of jodi an in that type would y things like you are so bad that is so debasing and i love i'm looking for a return missionary that is even more freaky. the challenge was to travis i want that freaky guy, i someone that can really be this love slave to me and so he would

talk dirty to her and try to raise the bar and excite her more. i think they were both engaged in consentual dirty talk with each other. >> judge jeanine: let's assume they were. she says that travis was controlling. do you think that is the case? >> well, if you listen to that tape there is no controlling in there whatsoever. >> judge jeanine: all right. >> we have jodi on the stand now says she felt used and abused like used toilet paper and that she was faking it. well, that is easy to say after you had five years to sit in prison and talk to psychologists and attorneys. >> judge jeanine: patty, you are on the phone right now. were you surprised when you heard that jodi killed travis alexander? >> i was really surprised when i heard that she killed travis. >> judge jeanine: how long have you known jodi arias? >> i have known jodi since the 6th grade. >> judge jeanine: since 6th

grade. all right. did you ever think she was capable of killing someone, stabbing them 28 times and basically almost decapitating them? >> absolutely not. the jodi that i knew could never do anything like that. so i mean hearing that, i just think it is drastic measures for jodi to do something like that. >> judge jeanine: had jodi ever spoken to you about her relationship with the victim her, trace gallagher viz alexander? travis alexander. she never complained to you or any one you know that she was being control and that she was a victim? >> no, i lost touch with jodi for about two years before the tragedy happened. >> judge jeanine: so now have you visited her in jail, patty? >> yes, i have. >> judge jeanine: and how does

she come across to you in jail? >> she comes across to me as the same jodi, very, very stressed out. you can see that it has taken a toll on her. >> judge jeanine: okay. all right. well, it should be an interesting verdict. patty, thanks for joining us. and dave, thank you for being with us. >> thank you. >> you're welcome. >> judge jeanine: and coming up our justice experts weigh in on the arias case. and later, our creep of the week. who do you think it is? [ dad ] find ? a. alright, another one just like that. right in the old bucket. good toss! see that's much better! that was good. you had your shoulder pointed, you kept your eyes on your target. let's do it again -- watch me. just like that one... [ male announcer ] the durability of the volkswagen passat.

pa down something he will be grateful for. good arm. that's the power of german engineering. ♪ back to you. we all work remotely so this is a big deal, our first full team gathering! i wanted to call on a few people. ashley, ashley marshall... here. since we're often all on the move, ashley suggested we use fedex office to hold packages for us. great job. [ applause ] thank you. and on a protocol note, i'd like to talk to tim hill about his tendency to use all caps in emails. [ shouting ] oh i'm sorry guys. ah sometimes the caps lock gets stuck on my keyboard. hey do you wanna get a drink later? [ male announcer ] hold packages at any fedex office location. there's nothing like our grilled lobster and lobster tacos. the bar harbor bake is really worth trying. [ male announcer ] get more during red lobster's lobsterfest. with the year's largest selection of mouth-watering bster entrees. ke our delicus lobster lover's dream, featuring two kinds of succulent lobster tails. or our savory, new grilled maine lobster

and bster tacos. it's back, but not for long. [ woman ] our guests go crazy for lobsterfest. my favorite entree is the lobster lover's dream. what's yours? come celebrate lobsterfest and sea food differently. try align. it's the number one ge recommended probiotic that helps maintain digestive balance. ♪ stay in the groove with align. ♪ need help keeping your digesve balance in sync?

try align. it's a probiotic that fortifies your digestive system with healthy bacteria 24/7. because your insides set the tone. stay in the groove with align. live from america's news headquarters i'm harris faulkner. people in central russia cleaning up after the huge meteor blew up in chunks to the earth.

a piece of the thing blew through a frozen lake. scientists saying the meteoric explosion was 30 times more powerful than the atomic bomb dropped on hir ois shima. also yesterday, an asteroid coming close are than ever to earth. scientists saying it is all just a coincidence. >> we now you know a bomb detonated by remote control took out a market in pakistan. at least 65 people killed. many of the injured are children. so far no, group has claimed responsibility but in recent months there have been several attacks against shiite muslims in the region. now, back to "justice." body slammed me on the floor at the foot of his bed. >> what did he do after he slammed you on the floor at the foot of h his bed?

>> it startled me. it didn't hurt but it startled me and so i kind of let out an unexpected sound. i guess it could be best described as a yelp sort of. can't really explain it. it just was unexpected to is startled me and then the sound came out and i think he misinterpreted because he said don't act like that hurts and he kicked me in the ribs. and that hurt for real. >> judge jeanine: interesting lady. joining me now my panel former assist yan d.a. dan shore who ran for d.a. in westchester county. criminal defense attorney bill aronwold. former head of the u.s. strike force and my good friend a professor of psychiatry at harvard university dr. john sharp and from radar online alexis who has been following the trial. doc, i got to start with you. this woman strikes me as a cold

person who is acting but she can't really act. >> and she acts so well that she doesn't even recognize she is doing it. you look into the eyes there is no emotion. it is not like your twinkle, judge. here feeling is all put away and some place so far you can't even relate to her. >> judge jeanine: but she is not insane and not offering an insanity defense because she lied so many times, right. >> basically a classic textbook case of how not to defend a client charged with murder. >> judge jeanine: why? >> most defense lawyers will tell you they don't want to put the client on the stand unless they have to. when your claim is self-defense you have to but you don't put the client on the stand for six days and have her testify about everything else except why it was self-defense which is what she has done. >> judge jeanine: still on direct now. six day its of testimony and haven't gotten to the fact that she stabbed him 27 times and shot him in the head.

>> judge jeanine: i didn't like her the first day i saw her. >> i think she is moreally insane. >> judge jeanine: i'm not going there yet. alexis, you have been in the courtroom. how does she come across? >> as this meek little girl that has been so tortured. the thing is i have is spoken to so many of travis' friends who have met he peteedly and -- repeatedly and they say this is nothing what she was like in real life. this is a show and they said she is absolutely acting and they can tell because she hesitates when she talks because she is trying to think of what the real story is. >> she is supposedly raising a self-defense claim. she hasn't raised one fact that makes that any kind of justification claim. >> judge jeanine: what was the line that he said if i he raped you. >> that was during phone sex. not okay but doesn't make out a self-defense claim of an imminent threat of harm at the time that he was stabbed

multiple times and shot and slashed from ear to ear. it is like a friend telling you aah long story and never getting to the point. the jury is not the going to care as muc by the end of the story. >> one of the problems in the self-defense case. he was shot and his throat slit and he was stabbed 27 times. that is not self-defense. that is rage. anger. lack of control. >> judge jeanine: let me throw from there the memory card from the camera of his being dragged across the floor she tried to wash in a washing machine. >> when she tells a story like patients i have seen that have severe personality disorder not that i can diagnose here on tv but she paints this landscape but you doesn't put herself in it. all this stuff and where is h her action and her role? she leaves that out. >> is she med kateed. >> she is not overmed kateed. i don't see any signs of her being overly medicate.

>> judge jeanine: what is with the lack of affect? >> that is the cardinal sign of her is severe personality problems. >> most likely she will be convicted. she needs sympathy from the jury so she is not executed at the end. >> judge jeanine: that is off the table. started with the phone sex and maybe they accomplished what they wanted to do. >> i have a problem with the fact that she has been on the stand this long. once she loses credibility with the jury on any issue then when it gets to the meat and potatoes of having to explain why this is self-defense the jury is going to tune her out. >> judge jeanine: does the jury buy any of this? >> in the beginning the jury bought -- everybody else is no. some of them won't even look her in the eye. 11 men and one woman. >> judge jeanine: really? 11 men and one woman? who pickd that jury. that defense right off the bat. >> alexis talks about the jury not looking her in the eye. on the portion of the tape you were playing before her defense

attorney won't even look her in the eye. >> when you stare into the abyss the abyss stares back at you. >> the key thing is eventually she will talk about the day travis alexander was shot and nothing she can say would make out a defense for the reason she stabbed him 27 times. >> she bought -- >> why does she lie about it after and say she wasn't there and then says that two masked intruder hes came in. >> judge jeanine: you know what the answer for that was, why she lied and said she wasn't there because she had never been charged with something before. did you read that? >> and the real reason -- the real reason is they hadn't confronted her with the evidence showing her she was at the scene and then had to change the story to say there were masked intruders. >> judge jeanine: the whole idea of her being a victim is fascinating. let me go to you one last time, doctor, on her issue you of her are ability to kill someone. she has no criminal record.

we know she was jealous because she was taking some other broad, excuse me, sorry, put the camera on me, i'm sorry, from her perspective there was someone else. >> she couldn't tolerate the loss. >> judge jeanine: but there is nothing in her history that says she is capable of killing someone like this. >> the best predicter of violence is a history of violence. here we have one woman who was so fractured in her psyche that she reached out and surprised us all with her rage. a crime of terrible passion but no one saw it coming. >> judge jeanine: and before we alexis isk here, aelection there anything you found out about her that we are not seeing in the courtroom. >> there was no proof that travis bought this underwear for her. never any pictures of her in it.ptember him a picture of h her in it. he loved naked pictures of her. nothing. the only ones that showed up were after heed died.

that might be another one of her lies. >> you are right. that is moral insanity. up next, the man known as a blade runner faces charges of murder. and don't forget to weigh in on the insta-poll. is $500 enough for the cruiseship passengers who had to walk in all that stuff? tweet me or judge jeanine on facebook. ♪ you know my heart burns for you... ♪

i'm up next, but now i'm sging the heartburn blues. hold on, prilosec isn't for fast relief. cue up alka-seltzer. it stops heartburn fast. ♪ oh what a relief it is! yeah. then how'd i get this... [ voice of dennis ] ...safe driving bonus check? every six months without an accident, allstate sends a check. ok. [ voice of dennis ] silence. are you in good hands?

can you start the day the way you want? can orencia help? could your "i want" become "i can"?

talk to youdoctor. orencia reduces many ra symptoms like pain, morning stiffness and progression of joint damage. it's helped new ra patients and those not helped enough by other treatments. do not take orencia with another biologic medicine for ra due to an increased risk of serious infection. serious side effects can occur including fatal infections. cases of lymphoma and lung cancer have been reported. due to an increased risk of serious infection. tell your doctor if you are prone to or have any infection like an open sore or the flu or a history of copd, chronic lung disease. orencia may worsen your copd. [ male announcer ] now learn about a program committed to you and copay assistance that can reduce monthly orencia out-of-pocket drug cost to $5. if you're not satisfied after 6 months, you get that money back. call 1-800-orencia.

♪ running on empty >> judge jeanine: south african runner oscar pistorius known as the blade runner because of the carbon fiber blades he runs on was charged friday with premeditated murder. his girlfriend model reeva steenkamp was shot four times through a bathroom door in pistorius home valentine's day. according to a south african newspaper steenkamp was killed two hours after police were called to the home to respond to reports of are argument by a neighbor. okay. now, we wal all watched oscar pistorius in the olympics and paralympics and rooted for him. what do we know about him.

>> a amazing not just someone who could run but could run in the olympics without having his real legs. the thing is he is this inspirational figure. as we know just because someone is larger than life and seems kind you don't know what they are leak at home, especially in domestic violence situations. they could have ave len a viole to them. >> we are looking at him on the screen. he has tremendous motivation. a tremendous competitive streak in him. but there is nothing that indicates in his background, is there, that he has any violence? >> there has been domestic violence incidents related to him. >> judge jeanine: what is an incident? >> what the police said there have been reports that they had to respond to related to domestic incidents. >> judge jeanine: with this woman? >> they didn't specify. >> in past they had been called other instances of arguing back and forth. >> judge jeanine: but physical? >> i'm not aware of anything that has been reported where there was any indication where

he physically assaulted anybody. loud arguing and verbal wily abusive. >> but the police have responded on multiple occasions. >> do we know anything about the police responding two hours before he shot her? >> there were reports that neighbors or passersby heard loud arguing inside and it was enough that they called the police and the police respond. >> but the police have been tight lipped about this and haven't said whether or not they actually spoke with her. they said that they responded to the home and then they left. his argument has been he was startled by an intruder which just doesn't jive with the fact that she was there and the police were there two hours earlier. >> judge jeanine: and and they don't have foi sacramento where get the information. can the reports are coming from his camp. >> i don't believe the statement is from his camp. they are denying that he committed intentional murder. >> from a defense standpoint.

>> do you think the police said it? >> there are some south africa media reports and they are not directly sourced to the police or the family. >> judge jeanine: i don't know who else would be saying it was an intruder he was shooting at. >> the media report. >> from a defense point of view if your claim is that you thought it was an intruder. there is problems that he has to overcome. i lived in a gated security. there was security guards to keep out unwanted guest or intruders. number two she was behind a closed bathroom door. >> judge jeanine: to me that is the key. shot four times in the bathroom behind the door. so the bullets went through the door. up next, more on the blade runner case. and he usually fights the bad guys. our creep of the week is spiderman who punches innocent moms in the face. what a creep. ♪ spins a web any time, can't you see, look out here comes the spiderman ♪

hi. hi. i'm here to pick up some cacti. it should be under stephens. the verizon share everything plan for small business. get a shareable pool of data... got enough joshua trees? ... on up to 25 devices. so you can spend less time... yea, the golden barrels... managing wireless costs and technology and more time driving your business potential. looks like we're going to need to order more agaves... ah! oh! ow! ... and more bandages. that's powerful. sharble data plus unlimited talk and text. now save $50 on a droid razr maxx hd by motorola.

after consulting with our legal representatives, we deeply regret the allegations of premeditated murder. we have no doubt here are there is no substance for the allegations. >> under south african law a person who fatally shoots an intruder must prove that he had a reasonable fear that the intruder posed a threat to his life. if reeva was shot through the bathroom door four times how big of a threat could she have been? >> based upon what we know about the history of oscar

pistorius and his competition and who he is what insight does that give you as a psychiatrist? >> a high intensity guy. he was numerous times in vehicle accidents. he is within a motor vehicle accident and boat accident. he had 170 stitches. he is a pump the up guy and it is possible that all of a sud isen at night maybe he wasn't in the best state of mind to use perfect judgment and he overreact. >> when you say he wasn't in the best state of mind. it is not like he had an alcohol or drug problem. it is valentine's morning, 3:00 in the morning and he was arguing with someone two hours earlier. >> doesn't add up. i try to take the best possible scenario. >> judge jeanine: let's talk about her. she was beautiful. and in fact she had a reality show thattarie aired don't fore first time. an advocate for domestic violence victims. do we know how she got involved

in this? >> they met at an awards show back in the fall. they have been so happy. she has been very outspoken on twitter about how much she loves him because he respects her. she spoke about that often. the fact that there was a domestic violence call seems the opposite of the way that she conducted her life and she was going to give a speech today i believe talking about supporting rape survivors. something that nobody knew h her history but there have been ex-girlfriends who have come forward and said they did have a bad relationship and mothers are other ex-girlfriends saying they were terrified for their own daughter's safety while they were dating him. >> judge jeanine: what do you do as a defense attorney there? >> one thing i want to find out is what did he do immediately after the shooting? immediately call for help or call for police? >> my understanding is he was carrying her down the stairs. >> to give her mouth to mouth. >> what was he saying. was he saying i accidentally

shot her, i she was an intruder. these are things to know. it is so early on. >> we don't know whether he was asleep at the time and heard noises and basiccal grabbed the gun. he may have actually thought there was an intruder? the house. >> my understanding is she came over. >> what about the emotion in court, judge? did you see when was really emoting. >> i would cry my eyes out, too, if somebody was charging me with premeditated murder. >> look at difference between jodi arias and this guy both charged with murdering their lover. >> what struck me as odd was he was sobbing audibly and the magistrate the judge was calming him down saying calm down, take it ease. is sit down. >> he is a national hero. he has been protected for years from anything to happen to him.

>> o.j. redo. >> the crying in court is just as consist went guilt as innocence. >> judge jeanine: there is a presumption of innocence at this point. >> there it, even in south africa. >> judge jeanine: that is the judge in me. great to have you here this evening. how to it is team for the results of the insta-poll. carnival cruise lines offered the people onboard the ineptly named triumph that turn inside a disaster this week a refund for the cruise and discount on a future cruise and $500. we asked you is $500 enough? if not, what should they say? >> john generously offered $18 trillion to each of the pass betters. thanks for that one, john. then there is robert? what does the ceo make for day? the same for every passenger. and mary ansays new bathrooms in their homes to always remind them of what happened. tony says carnival did more than they had to. i applaud them.

really? how about -- and jeff, our society is lawsuit happy. bad things and accidents happen. carnival is trying to do the right thing by offering $500? what about the fact that i have too pay my baby sitter or pet sitter and all of the package outside that was brought to me in the mail, soaked in rain. i don't think are so. and finally, frank says they should get their heads checked and a good swift kick for good measure just for going on a carnival cruise. and now, for creep of the week. and this one has got my justice sense tingling. this week it is a case of the not so friendly neighborhood spiderman. so they say the saying goes with great power comes great responsibility. but the superhero impersoniater phillip williams who takes pictures with tourists in times square didn't get that message.

after taking a photo with two kids earlier this week the creep takes a swing at their mother after she refused to give him a tip. now, he faces assault and harassment charges. spiderman got his powers from the bite of a radio active spider. maybe phillip williams was bitten by a radio active creep. no matter what caused him to turn from his ways he takes the top spot as this week's creep. we have been reading your e-mails and facebook comments and tweets and we haven't foregotten about benghazi and your questions about the 30 odd individual there's. if you know any of those survivors of that horrific night, e-mail us their names and addresses and let us know where they are. we would love to talk to them. captioned by closed captioning services, inc. are